We Buy Records

If you have records you’re interested in selling, please read the FAQs below which explain the process of selling your records to us. We’re open daily from 11-7.

Questions? Please reach out to us.

Sell us your records!

We’re always buying record collections of all sizes. Below are answers to questions we typically get asked about our buying process. If you have any additional questions give us a call, send us an email, or stop by the store. We’d be happy to discuss the possibility of purchasing your records. Our phone number, email address, physical address, and store hours are below the FAQs.

Genres we buy: Rock, Jazz, Blues, R&B / Soul / Funk, Soundtracks, Country, Rap, Punk, Metal, Christmas, & Audiophile. 
We do not buy: Classical, Easy Listening, Show Tunes, Opera, Big Band, Comedy, or Children’s.

That’s okay! We buy vinyl albums from the 50’s – today. We’re interested in all ages of 33 1/3 LPs (this is what most people think about when they think of records.)

1/3 to 1/2 of what we think we can re-sell them for. Most of the used records in our store sell for between $2 – $20. Although, we do sell more valuable records for much more than that. If you’re curious what your records are worth we encourage you to take a look around the store to see if we have any of the same records in similar condition for sale right now.

Record values vary greatly depending on condition and the unique pressing (year it was made, country it was made in, pressing plant it came from). We have many years of experience determining the value of records and have a reputation of paying fairly for records that are worth a pretty penny. If it’s actually worth $1,000 you’ll be leaving with a fat check!

We buy records in a variety of conditions but not all. The better the condition, the more it’s worth; some records are sought after even in lesser condition. We do require that records have their original jacket. If in doubt about the condition of some or all of your records bring ’em by and we’ll take a look!

Most of the time we’re not interested in the entire collection. We can only buy records we think we can re-sell. There are various charities in the Atlanta area that accept vinyl donations and we make regular trips to drop off records for donation. We’re happy to take any records that you’d like to donate.

Yes! If you have 1,000+ records we can discuss the possibility of a house call. We will travel to states throughout the Southeast and no collection is too large. Please send us an email to discuss – buyer@comebackvinyl.com

Yes! We pay about 20% more in store credit.

Totally! Even if you only have one record we’d be happy to look at it.

We do not. If you bring your records to us we trust that you’re interested in selling them, not having them appraised. We won’t break down our offer record-by-record, we’ll just let you know how much we can pay for a batch of records.

You do not need an appointment. You can stop by any time we’re open. Store hours and physical address are below these FAQs.

Yes. Even if it’s a small amount.

We’ve been buying and selling used records since 2014 and we’ve never once lost anyone’s records. We have a storage room in our store dedicated to records that have been dropped off. Everyone’s records are in bags or boxes that are individually marked with that person’s name and phone number.

Typically 2 – 3 days but we ask for up to a week just to be safe.

Please see the parking map on the bottom of this page. We recommend the area highlighted in yellow but any of these parking areas will do.

Yes! We have a hand truck and are happy to come out to your car and bring your records into the store. Call us when you park or come on in and we’ll walk out with you.

Yes! We’ll give you a slip of paper that has the date you dropped off your records, your name, our contact info, and our buying disclaimer.

We’ll send you an email. If we don’t hear back after a few days we’ll follow up via phone.

If you have any other questions please give us a call, send us an email, or stop by the store. We’d be happy to discuss!

“Had a very nice experience selling a box of old 70s and 80s records. They are in downtown Alpharetta, so finding parking isn’t easy. We found a spot in a lot behind their store and they brought out a hand truck and took the box back in with them.

“Since we had already filled out the paperwork, we didn’t have to go back in. Nice of them to come to our car. Also felt a fair price was given after they checked over each record. Mailed us a check that same week. Highly recommend if you have old records to sell!”

Brenda M. – Yelp Reviewer

Swing by any time we’re open.

We’re at the shop every day from 11am – 7pm

    Your Bag
    Your bag is emptyreturn to shop
      Calculate Shipping

      What will you find next?

      Grooves we love.

      "Finding Wildflowers (Alternate Versions)"

      "Cuttin Grass - Vol. 2 (The Cowboy Arms Sessions)"

      "The Battle At Garden's Gate"

      "Remixes"

      "Call Me By Your Name (Soundtrack)"

      "Evermore"

      "Damn."

      "Folklore"

      $26.99$28.99

      $34.99